The Patriots’ draft was universally panned by NFL analysts

The Patriots’ draft was universally panned by NFL analysts

ESPN’s Mel Kiper gave the Patriots a C+, tying them with the Cowboys for his lowest rating.

“Are we allowed to question a draft from Bill Belichick?” Kiper wrote. “Value matters in the draft.”

He didn’t assume Peculiar deserved to be a first-round pick out, and mentioned Thornton wasn’t amongst his most sensible 25 receivers, as “he needs a lot of work on his all-around game.”

Kiper’s ESPN colleague, Swampscott local Todd McShay, was once just a little extra diplomatic, however nonetheless referred to as it a “confusing” draft, with Peculiar as a “reach.”

“Tough class to find a real standout,” McShay wrote.

Chad Reuter of gave the Patriots a C+, forward of most effective the Colts, who were given a C.

And Professional Soccer Focal point gave the Patriots a D. The Jaguars, Saints, Commanders, and Chargers were given the next-lowest grades with a C+, which displays you the way a lot PFF hated the Patriots’ draft. PFF had Peculiar as their 86th easiest pick out (the Patriots took him twenty ninth) they usually had Thornton ranked 192nd (the Patriots took him fiftieth).

Quick draft grades are just a little foolish. Nobody in reality is aware of how the possibilities will pan out, and Belichick may be proper about Peculiar, Thornton and the opposite choices.

However the grades are noteworthy since the mavens, in particular reliable league companions from ESPN and, hardly ever criticize a draft. Virtually everybody will get an A or a B only for taking part.

However the Patriots are getting ripped to shreds, and Belichick isn’t getting any good thing about the doubt.

A couple of different notes from draft weekend:

▪ The analytics crowd hates the Patriots’ draft, too. One chart making the rounds throughout social media in comparison the adaptation in a crew’s precise draft capital vs. anticipated draft capital vs. the consensus rating of possibilities — mainly a statistical have a look at which groups matched their choices maximum intently with the consensus of the entire primary draft mavens.

The Patriots fared the worst through a mile. 9 in their 10 choices had been thought to be a “reach,” with Thornton and fourth-round cornerback Jack Jones over-drafted, each and every through greater than 100 spots.

Once more, no person is aware of how those gamers are going to prove. However given the guidelines we now have now, everybody turns out to hate the Patriots’ draft.

▪ Let’s be sure for a second. My favourite pick out of the weekend: Fourth-round quarterback Bailey Zappe from Western Kentucky. I do not know if he’s any excellent, however I really like the speculation of choosing a quarterback within the center rounds. Zappe was once the 5th quarterback taken off the board.

The Patriots can have discovered their franchise quarterback in Mac Jones, however you’ll by no means have sufficient at crucial place in sports activities. The Packers used to have a rule of drafting a quarterback once a year, even if they’d Brett Favre. It helped them in finding Kurt Warner and Matt Hasselbeck, along with drafting Aaron Rodgers. The Packers’ longtime GM was once Ron Wolf, whose son, Eliot, is within the Patriots’ entrance place of business.

The Patriots have Brian Hoyer as their backup, however they want any other quarterback to increase. Jarrett Stidham is coming into the general yr of his contract, and the Patriots obviously don’t see a lot in him after 3 years. The Patriots removed Ryan Mallett as he entered the general yr of his contract, and Stidham seems to be at the similar trail.

Preferably, Zappe can display sufficient this yr or subsequent to be the number one backup. And if Zappe can nip at Jones’s heels and make him really feel uncomfortable, the entire higher.

Jones had a forged rookie season, however the very last thing the Patriots need is for Jones to turn out to be complacent or really feel like he has a tenured seat because the starter. The Patriots didn’t draft Zappe to compete with Jones, however ask Drew Bledsoe how at ease he felt with some sixth-round child impressing the coaches in apply each day.

▪ Thornton, out of Baylor, turns out to move towards lots of the Patriots’ scouting dispositions at receiver. They hardly ever take the 40-yard sprint under consideration and as a substitute prioritize the 3-cone drill. However Thornton was once an absolute burner within the 40 — his 4.28 was once the third-highest on the Mix and primary amongst receivers — however his 3-cone time was once a dreadful 7.25.

Thornton stands 6-2 and 180 kilos, and PFF isn’t keen on his skill to damage tackles, noting that he averaged 3.9 yards after the catch and broke simply 11 tackles on 143 profession receptions. However Greg Cosell, the movie guru at NFL Movies, mentioned Thornton “was competitively tough and gritty,” referred to as him “the most vertically explosive receiver in the draft,” and mentioned he has “a physical dimension to his game even though he’s 181 pounds.” As a velocity burner at the out of doors, Thornton is most definitely a alternative for Nelson Agholor, whether or not it’s this yr or subsequent yr.

▪ Just a little stunned the Patriots didn’t draft any linebackers, however my jaw didn’t drop to the ground or anything else. The standard linebacker spot is solely no longer as necessary a place in as of late’s NFL, and the Patriots, like maximum groups, have a host of outsized safeties manning the location.

Between safeties Kyle Dugger, Adrian Phillips and Jabrill Peppers, plus linebackers Matthew Judon, Ja’Whaun Bentley, and a host of unproven gamers, the Patriots most definitely have sufficient at linebacker this yr. It wouldn’t marvel me if the Patriots introduced again Dont’a Hightower for yet another yr, too.

Nevertheless it’s unexpected the Patriots didn’t do extra to enhance their run protection, which completed twenty fifth final yr in reasonable achieve allowed (4.5 yards in keeping with strive). Their most effective draft pick out within the entrance seven was once defensive take on Sam Roberts within the 6th around.

▪ The Patriots drafted two working backs on Day 3 — Pierre Robust, a lock to make the roster, and Kevin Harris, who has a excellent shot. The Patriots had one emptiness with the departure of Brandon Bolden, however there is usually a numbers crunch. Rhamondre Stevenson is a roster lock, and Damien Harris most definitely isn’t going any place since he’s making league minimal this yr.

J.J. Taylor, energetic for simply 5 video games final season, might be at the manner out. It additionally makes me ponder whether James White, coming back from a serious hip harm, may have to start out the season at the Bodily Not able to Carry out listing, which might stay him out no less than six weeks.

Ben Volin may also be reached at

Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published.